College papers help


Porphyrias lover and my last duchess comparison essay

Hire Writer The Duke describes how people are surprised by her seductive, passionate glance, and he gets very jealous when people admire the painting.

This leads him to hide it behind a curtain. She metaphorically and literally brings warmth to his life; without her it is cold. This also uses the foreshadowing device maybe indicating her throat was slit.

The Duke justifies his actions by claiming his wife did not deserve her position as Duchess, or live up to the responsibilities that her noble stance required. Unlike the Duchess who flirts with everyone and does not show the Duke the respect he craves, Porphyria does worship her lover: This is the reason she is killed, as he does not want her feelings to change and the affair to end because he feels so passionate for her.

I think this is quite disturbing however as he tries to do it in a pleasant way, but ultimately this is still a murder.

Downloading prezi...

The Duke on the other hand shows no remorse for his actions. This calm casual approach is very cold and calculating and I do not think he ever really loved his wife; if he did, jealousy and respect was more important rather than to try and remedy the situation and put his unease at rest. This desire for her is not out of love but just another addition to his collection.

I think by doing this the Duke is making a sly reference to his own aims in capturing his next wife. I believe he thinks of himself as Neptune; powerful and ruling, and he compares this young woman to a sea-horse, in the way that she could be so easily tamed. Time has frozen for him and he can capture the moment forever suggested by the use of the expression: The modern reader is given an insight into the way relationships between men and women were viewed in the last century, and earlier, during the time of the Renaissance.

Without doubt, men had the dominant role, and women had little personal freedom. Women were duty-bound to show unquestioning respect for the men in their lives, regardless of how they were treated. In fact, she is completely the opposite, and as such, she is fulfilling the role of a male fantasy by taking a dominant role.

Compare & Contrast ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ and ‘My Last Duchess’ Essay

He cannot move on and is tied to Porphyria forever. It is not until the end the possession comes clear in both poems where the Duke is obsessed be the Duchess because she is a beautiful object and the lover is obsessed because of his eternal love for Porphyria.

Comparison between Porphyria’s Lover and My Last Duchess Essay

Another genre of love is Romantic Love. Sonnets are poems with 14 lines and a regular rhythm, rhyme scheme and structure.

Comparison between ‘My Last Duchess’ and ‘Porphyria’s Lover’ Essay

This is not a sonnet but is based upon a celebration. It was written by Christian Rossetti 1830-1894and most of her work was religious in nature, which is reflected in the poem: Love is a guiding light implying it will overcome any difficulties in a relationship. The use of rhetorical questions involves the reader and I think they are very effective as the reader is made to think about the different ways you can love someone and our first love, which we all remember.

She cannot enumerate the different ways she can love her husband for they are innumerable. This is slightly an idealistic view of love as we never know what will happen in the future and if love does end with someone it may start back up again with someone else. This is a strong claim to make considering he is so famous for his many sonnets.

  • Without doubt, men had the dominant role, and women had little personal freedom;
  • Thus, his love is no less than a manifestation of his honor, which he is unable to preserve;
  • This detail shows the beauty of Porphyria;
  • He is obsessed with her;
  • She does want his life to come to an end just because hers has;
  • The Duke told all his displeasure with his first wife in order to make clear to the second woman what sort of conduct he will expect from her, like a warning to his possible wife to be.

It does not address love after death. All three poems are very positive and as I have mentioned talk about love in an ideal way but unfortunately love does not always run smoothly and so I think these poems are an exaggerated view of love and cannot be relied upon when querying love itself.

When you love someone and you are in a relationship it will always come to an end due to the death of on person. You can still love someone once they are dead and it can be everlasting which is repeated in many of the poems but the physical aspect of love will come to an end when someone dies. The next three poems are all related to love and death and have different views on it.

  • When you love someone and you are in a relationship it will always come to an end due to the death of on person;
  • The way in which she was strangled by her lover with her own hair is like she strangled herself — almost as a way of releasing herself;
  • These two characters of Browning are very different;
  • Brownings monologues are addressed to a character or a group of characters and, the presence of a listener is suggested;
  • In My Last Duchess, the Duke looks at the painting of his last duchess and trails off to the past;
  • Hire Writer The Duke describes how people are surprised by her seductive, passionate glance, and he gets very jealous when people admire the painting.

The tone of the three poems varies. I think this is because Rossetti wrote this when she was only nineteen and at this time people died at a young age and so we get the impression that she was writing it for later life as her death would come sooner rather than later.

The whole poem therefore has a more personal touch than the others and implies that she wants to be remembered for the right reasons. She puts his happiness first and this idea is highlighted throughout the poem. The two verses are clearly differentiated by the use of instructions in the first and the benefits of her death in the second. This is slightly confusing, as the reader does not know what Rossetti wants her lover to do.

Blog Archive

We never come across details of how she died or bluntly stating she is dead and this is why the poem is much more positive. The concept of eternal love runs throughout all the poems in different ways. In these three poems they highlight this and hope they will be re united one day.

This is simple yet affective as it signifies that obviously you cannot hold hands now the person has dies but yet there is still hope that one day they will be reunited.

Compare and contrast Porphyrias lover and My last Duchess

Both these two poems from Romantic Love explain how love does not alter and sustains even after death. She does want his life to come to an end just because hers has. However love has many different aspects to it including obsession and death, which we do not contemplate for.

  • This is just like the Duke in the poem, he lives life by regularity, his life is in a very controlled pattern, very regular and formal, just like the couplets;
  • From the poem, we can see how ruthless and grasping the Duke is;
  • Another reason could be that people who have seen the picture ask why she had the look and he had to tell them that it was not him that made her look so joyful but just some common artist and this he would view a weakness, so he grew to resent the Duchess;
  • The concept of eternal love runs throughout all the poems in different ways;
  • The lover in both poems kills the woman but not himself.

The poems deal with all these issues but in conclusion most have one common theme of eternal love. They exhibit the idea of being reunited one day but in different ways. The Duke has the picture, which he can admire to remind himself of her as well as showing off to his guests. Love is something we all want to encounter one day but as we have seen can have bitter consequences.

How to cite this page Choose cite format: