College papers help


The social injustices of herman melvilles time in the novel billy budd

He never went to college, and he never had the things that most writers of his day had; for in that time, writing alone was not normally enough to sustain you.

  • Yet Billy Budd shows a change in style;
  • In the novella Billy Budd, Melville uses the ordinary people of his day to highlight the social injustices of the time;
  • Barbara Johnson has this to say about the characters;
  • It was from this time that his great talent for allegories would arise;
  • Only by his death does Billy become more than he was in life.

While his contemporaries were lawyers, doctors, clerks, businessmen, politicians, and other white-collar workers, Melville learned to write while working on a number of different ships as a crewmember.

On ships, it was a great skill to be able to tell stories of land and sea, to be able to transport the people on board to another time and place.

Melville first learned to tell a story here. He would talk of epic sea battles. He would talk about brave sailors and dastardly villains. It was from this time that his great talent for allegories would arise. But it was not until his final novel, which was not printed until after his death, that he wrote his masterpiece. In the novella Billy Budd, Melville uses the ordinary people of his day to highlight the social injustices of the time.

Billy Budd shows how we see heroes, villains, and war today, but in reality it is best when you understand the context. Billy Budd was written in the late nineteenth century 1888-1891.

America had expanded from sea to shining sea. The frontier had been closed in 1890, and America could no longer expand. The country did not have a great navy.

In fact it was struggling to rebuild itself after the bloody Civil War. The United States was attempting to rise above its beginnings, but America was stuck in a paradox. To become a world power, America would need both overseas colonies and a large peacetime navy.

Indeed, these two were inseparable, for a military fleet was necessary to seize and hold colonies, and these colonies provided bases indispensable to maintaining such a fleet. The crucial question being debated was this: In essence, Melville uses Billy as an allegory for the young United States trying to do what was right, while Captain Vere has all the characteristics of imperialism that Melville had detested all his life.

The story foresees the consequences of unbridled militarism and imperialism, which ignores the rules of man not only in colonized lands, but also among the people forced to do the fighting and the colonizing. By going into the past to explore the consequences of the triumph of militarism and imperialism in England, it foreshadows the future, with the consequences of the triumph of militarism and imperialism in America.

The story shows how a country can often be blinded by current events and not see the consequences of its actions. Having decided upon the absolute necessity for maintaining unweakened the strength of the social fabric, Melville shudders when he contemplates the price exacted in terms of human values; and Billy Budd became the balance-sheet upon which he reckoned the price men have to pay for the ordered society which they have to have. To the destruction of innocent persons, moreover, it was necessary to add the mental suffering of the individual forced to make moral judgements.

  1. What purpose does it serve? Is it called to guide him to a right decision?
  2. Captain Vere is of two minds throughout the story.
  3. The country did not have a great navy. The frontier had been closed in 1890, and America could no longer expand.

Vere believes that the Naval Code is more important than the concepts of right and wrong. The names of the ships that Billy serves on are both allegories. The Indomitable is an allegory for something that is huge and awe inspiring. The Rights-of-Man symbolizes the smaller, more moral decision people often forget about.

Billy journeys from ship to ship. The machinery of the Royal Navy traps Billy; he becomes a cog rather than a thinking human being. When Billy places his faith completely in the royal Navy his fate is sealed.

No one must agree with everything that the country does. There should always be philosophical debate about current events. The leaders of a country will do whatever they want unless the common people watch out for their rights. His very reliance on the rules dooms him. After Claggart accuses Billy of attempted mutiny, Vere decides to confront the two men with each other in his cabin. There Billy, angered by the charge, confused and frustrated by his stammer, kills Claggart. This plan does not make sense.

Claggart would have accused, and Billy would have denied. Vere calls a court martial. During the trial the members of the court seem reluctant to hang Billy, and the Captain has to talk them into it. But it is hard to understand why Vere calls the court at all. What purpose does it serve? Is it called to guide him to a right decision? But Vere has already made his decision. In any case the court does not guide him; he guides the court. Perhaps he thinks the court will overrule him and release Billy.

  • Only by his death does Billy become more than he was in life;
  • Billy budd herman melville buy table of contents all subjects book summary about billy budd melville creates the tale as radical social commentary;
  • He had always prized the heart over the head;
  • Herman melville 1819 - 1891 and his final novel, billy budd melville, herman omoo;
  • Herman melville 1819-1891 similarly in billy budd, melville connects his critique of , social critique, and literary form in the sea novels of herman;
  • He lacks the fire that transforms people into something more.

But Vere has reserved for himself the right of supervising the proceedings. Obviously all Vere wanted is to have on record a trial agreeing with his decision. Withim talks about the psyche of Captain Vere: Stripped of verbiage, Vere is saying that men cannot think for themselves, that form and habit can control men as if they were no more than beasts.

In this light, Vere, far from being a wise man, balanced in his judgements and fair in his attitudes, is discovered to be narrow, literal, prejudiced, completely circumscribed by the needs of the navy, less compassionate than his officers, and lastly, guilty of that worst of naval sins, over-prudence.

Vere shows that he would rather sacrifice innocence than give up control. Melville shows throughout the book that Vere is a careful man and that he is well read, well mannered, and basically a gentleman. The very crew he is worried about mutinying is the same that holds Billy in such high regard. None except Claggart, whom he kills, had ever said anything unbecoming about Billy Budd. This was obviously what Melville thought. He had always prized the heart over the head.

Captain Vere is of two minds throughout the story. His evil side is represented by the spectre of war in his communications with Claggart, and Billy represents his good side. Good and evil are always two sides of the same coin. Vere attempts to be portrayed as a just and moral man.

But when it is not the easy way out, he chooses his duty over his heart. He eschewed the straight narratives of many of his contemporaries. Yet Billy Budd shows a change in style.

The social injustices of herman melvilles time in the novel billy budd

His weapon for his final attack on the social injustices of the time is his use of irony. In all other respects it is similar to his earlier works.

In Billy Budd his barbed comments often find their mark. Melville often relates the common man to that of a savage and that of the ruling class to that of civilized men. Captain Vere, upon hearing the words, is shocked. He addresses the crowd. The character of Billy Budd is one of simplicity itself. Billy wants nothing more than to live his days in a virtuous way. Ironically, it is his saintly virtue that sets him apart from his seafaring comrades for most of the novella.

At the end of the story, that which had set Billy apart from his shipmates in life bonds them indelibly at the moment of his death. By then, the sympathy of the men is not with the Captain, but with the virtuous Billy.

Billy is sacrificed, but his ballad-singing mates seize upon this as a symbol of their lives.

The social injustices of herman melvilles time in the novel billy budd

Billy accepts his fate without question. Joyce Adler talks about his position: Billy accepts his impressment without complaint. There is no one resembling him on the Bellipotent-a rereading of the social injustices of herman melvilles time in the novel billy budd dedication after the novel is read will remind one-no independent spirit to speak up firmly for Billy.

He felt overall that man was virtuous, as is evident in the basic good nature of the crew on both ships in the novel. Sure, there are always a few bad seeds like Claggart or men subverted from their original intentions like Captain Vere. Yet most men are, like Billy, not extraordinary, and lack the courage to stick up for themselves even when the case is clear that they are right.

The character of Vere shows not just the tendency of those in power to attempt to keep the status quo but the tendency of those in the military to fall in love with war. Though every military man would say that the ultimate goal of the armed services is peace, how many sailors or soldiers are happy during peacetime?

Adler had this to say on the matter: Claggart is the obvious villain of the story. Melville gives him no redeeming qualities. It is interesting to note that Melville made Moby Dick and Claggart, his two most evil creations, both white instead of black. The character of Claggart is so unrealistic and so uncompromisingly evil that his only purpose is to expose the morality of the other major players Captain Vere and Billy Budd.

His character eventually shows the unwavering faith of Billy and the underlying madness of Captain Vere. Melville goes to great length to show the differences in his characters. Billy is a novice; Claggart is civilized and evil.

Barbara Johnson has this to say about the characters: What she means by this is that when Billy kills Claggart, although he is the innocent, in the eyes of the system he has now become the villain. Indeed, in the only scene in the entire book when Billy the common man finally stands up for what he believes, he is found guilty by the very system he has put his faith in from day one. By this turn of events, Melville shows irony to be a double-edged sword.