College papers help


Is there a link between mmr vaccination and autism

  • The Committee believes the matter is likely to be clarified by a better understanding of the causes of autism;
  • Rather, they continued to rise;
  • Fourth, measles, mumps, or rubella vaccine viruses have not been found to cause chronic intestinal inflammation or loss of intestinal barrier function;
  • For children born in 1992, according to the U;
  • Should they apply the methylmercury guidelines to ethylmercury?
  • Three specific hypotheses have been proposed:

For children born in 1992, according to the U. For children born in 2004, about 1 in 68 children would receive an ASD diagnosis. The role of vaccines has been questioned, along with other possible risk factors for ASD, such as genetic predisposition, advanced parental age, and other environmental factors.

  • MMR vaccination and autism;
  • In the United Kingdom, 71 MMR-vaccinated autistic children were compared with 284 MMR-vaccinated matched control children through use of the Doctor's Independent Network, a general practice database [ 12 ];
  • The results were published in the New England Journal of Medicine;
  • No relationship between thimerosal exposure and autism diagnosis was observed;
  • First, the self-referred cohort did not include control subjects, which precluded the authors from determining whether the occurrence of autism following receipt of MMR vaccine was causal or coincidental;
  • Because signs of autism may appear around the same time children receive the MMR vaccine, some parents may worry that the vaccine causes autism.

Vaccines have perhaps received more scrutiny that any other speculated cause of ASD, and the great majority of scientists, physicians, and public health researchers have come to the conclusion that there is no association between vaccines and autism. The MMR Hypothesis The story of how vaccines came to be questioned as a cause of autism dates back to the 1990s.

  • The authors observed no differences between case and control children in practitioner consultation rates—a surrogate for parental concerns about their child's development—within 6 months after MMR vaccination, which suggests that the diagnosis of autism was not temporally related to MMR vaccination;
  • Evidence is strong that the original study should not have been published not merely because it was poorly conducted, but also because it was a product of research fraud;
  • One such target is the number of vaccines given to children;
  • The immune response elicited from the vast antigen exposure of unattenuated viral replication supersedes that of even multiple, simultaneous vaccines;
  • In England, researchers prospectively followed 12,810 children for whom they had complete vaccination records who were born during 1991—1992, and they found no relationship between early thimerosal exposure and deleterious neurological or psychological outcomes [ 26 ];
  • Two conclusions are evident from these data.

Part of this hypothesis — that vaccination was associated with autism — had been suggested previously a few researchers.

For example, Fudenberg, in a small pilot study published in a non-mainstream journal, posited this relationship[8], as did Gupta in a review of possible treatments for autism. In 1998, Wakefield, along with 12 co-authors, published a case series study in the Lancet claiming that they found evidence, in many of the 12 cases they studied, of measles virus in the digestive systems of children who had exhibited autism symptoms after MMR vaccination.

Wakefield himself had filed for a patent for a single-antigen measles vaccine in 1997 and so would seem to have a potential financial interest in promoting this view. Press outlets covered the news widely and frightened parents began to delay or completely refuse vaccination for their children, both in Britain and the United States.

MMR and autism

MMR vaccination rates in Britain plummeted. After examining the records for all twelve children, Deer noted that the statements made in the paper did not match numbers from the records in any category: The Lancet paper claimed that six of the children had all three of these conditions; according to the records, not a single child actually did.

In an accompanying editorial, BMJ editor in chief Fiona Godlee and co-authors Jane Smith and Harvey Marcovitch examine the damage to public health caused by a tiny study based on parental recall with no control group — a study that turned out to be almost entirely fraudulent, but whose impact continues to this day.

Evidence is strong that the original study should not have been published not merely because it was poorly conducted, but also because it was a product of research fraud. The Thimerosal Hypothesis MMR is not the only vaccine or vaccine component that has been targeted for scrutiny by those who suspect vaccination might be related to autism.

After the MMR controversy died down, critics turned their questions to thimerosal, a mercury-containing preservative used in some vaccines.

Measles, Mumps, and Rubella (MMR) Vaccine Safety Studies

Thimerosal had never been used in MMR, as antimicrobial agents are not used in live vaccines. With heightened attention to known and potential harmful effects of such exposures, the U. Food and Drug Administration FDA in 1999 requested that drug companies report on amounts of mercury in their products. The results for mercury in vaccines, in the form of thimerosal, exceeded FDA guidelines for exposures to the kind of mercury found in fish. Mercury in fish appears in the form of methylmercury, which is not readily metabolized and excreted in the human body.

It is known to cause, at certain levels of high exposure, harmful neurological effects. The mercury in thimerosal metabolizes in the body to ethylmercury, a compound that, while not widely studied at the time, was thought to be much less harmful than methylmercury.

Global Vaccine Safety

Should they apply the methylmercury guidelines to ethylmercury? Was there cause for concern about exposure to mercury in childhood vaccines?

  1. Therefore, the available data suggest that vaccines do not weaken the immune system.
  2. Although a trend toward increasing autism diagnoses by year of birth was confirmed, no change in the rates of autism diagnoses after the 1987 introduction of MMR vaccine was observed. In 1998, a report was published describing 12 patients with inflammatory bowel conditions and regressive developmental disorders consisting primarily of autism.
  3. Autism is not an immune-mediated disease. More than 3 million person-years of observation during 1988—1999 confirmed an increase in autism diagnoses despite stable MMR vaccination rates.
  4. In 2004, a report by the Institute of Medicine IOM concluded that there is no link between autism and MMR vaccine, and that there is no link between autism and vaccines that contain thimerosal as a preservative.

Unable to answer these questions immediately, together with the American Academy of Pediatrics and other groups, they called for vaccine companies to reduce or eliminate the use of thimerosal in vaccines. Additionally, studies were planned to investigate whether there were harmful effects in children exposed to the amount of mercury in vaccines.

Activists and others became concerned about the safety of thimerosal at this point, and they posited that autism could be an outcome of exposure to mercury in vaccines. The Institute of Medicine undertook a comprehensive safety review of the issue. Their preliminary report, published in 2001, stated that the committee did not find enough evidence to support or reject a causal relationship between mercury in vaccines and neurodevelopmental disorders.

Rather, they continued to rise. One such target is the number of vaccines given to children. Many vaccines have been added to the childhood immunization schedule since the 1980s, and some critics have voiced concern that this increase in vaccine exposure results in autism.

However, no evidence of an association between increased exposure to vaccines and autism has appeared. Yet the amounts of aluminum used in vaccines are small in comparison to other exposures to aluminum, such as in breast milk and infant formula. Aluminum in vaccines has not been implicated in any infant or childhood health problems.

Still, critics continue to question the issue. Not only do they question the relationship between MMR and thimerosal and autism, they bring up further culprits they believe might play a role in development of autism.

Researchers continue to examine these questions, but there is no evidence that these factors play a role in autism development. Most autism researchers hold that the causes of autism are many and include genetic and environmental factors, but do not involve vaccines.

MMR vaccination and autism: is there a link?

Evaluating changes in the prevalence of the autism spectrum disorders ASDs. The rise in autism and the role of age at diagnosis.

Autism spectrum disorder ASD. National Institutes of Health. National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke. Autism spectrum disorder fact sheet. National Academies Press, 2004.

  1. Table 2 View large Download slide Studies that fail to support an association between thimerosal in vaccines and autism.
  2. Four other studies have been reviewed in detail elsewhere [ 28 ] but are not discussed here because their methodology is incomplete and unclear and, thus, cause difficulty in drawing meaningful conclusions.
  3. Evaluating changes in the prevalence of the autism spectrum disorders ASDs.
  4. Autism rates increased coincident with a decrease in MMR vaccination rates. The Lancet paper claimed that six of the children had all three of these conditions; according to the records, not a single child actually did.
  5. Was there cause for concern about exposure to mercury in childhood vaccines? Autism is not an immune-mediated disease.

Is measles vaccination a risk factor for inflammatory bowel disease? Dialysable lymphocyte extract DLyE in infantile onset autism: Immunology and immunologic treatment of autism.

Proc Natl Autism Assn Chicago.