College papers help


The effects of aids on our society and the importance of the this issue

The negative impact on public health Edwin J. HIV criminalization is bad policy based on bad science. Missed the press conference yesterday on HIVCrim? Sharing info about harms… 25 Jul 2018 RT jiasociety: Stop criminalisation of HIV!

Leading experts call on the criminal justice system to ensure science informs the application of the law in criminal cases rela… 25 Jul 2018 Groundbreaking Consensus Statement released by world-leading HIV scientists to ensure that science informs the appl… https: They suggest that these significant personal and financial resources could be more productively used to expand evidence-informed and human rights-based HIV-prevention efforts.

They also suggest that using the criminal law to address potential or actual HIV exposure or transmission might be counterproductive in the following ways: Prosecuting individuals for behaviour that is very unlikely to expose someone to HIV e. By providing further incentive for people to avoid learning their HIV status. People aware they are living with HIV may be less likely to seek support in their efforts to avoid infecting others if they fear that information they share about risky behaviour could be used against them in the criminal justice system.

These, and other issues, are further explored in the following sections. The impact on people who are aware they are living with HIV People living with HIV may be negatively affected by using the criminal law to address potential or actual HIV exposure or transmission in multiple ways. Increasing HIV-related stigma While it is difficult to empirically prove that laws and prosecutions for potential or actual HIV exposure or transmission have had a direct impact on worsening HIV-related stigma,1 this is a common assertion, for example, by: The opinions of people living with HIV are significant because perceptions of HIV-related stigma affect their willingness to access HIV-related treatment, care and support, which has major public health implications.

International research is underway in this area, undertaken by a global partnership of local, national and international communities and organisations.

Global Impact of Human Immunodeficiency Virus and AIDS

Researchers from the United Kingdom observed that some HIV-positive gay men reacted to the fear of criminal justice system involvement by not disclosing their HIV-positive status prior to sex that risked HIV exposure. The investigators noted that this was an "unexpected" finding. As discussed in the chapter: Responsibilitya sexual partner who wrongly believes that he or she is with an HIV-negative person may be more inclined to engage in higher-risk activities such as unprotected vaginal or anal intercourse.

In addition, should a person living with HIV be too afraid to disclose their HIV-positive status to a partner after unprotected intercouse out of concern that this might place them at risk of criminal sanctions, this might also lead to their sexual partner failing to access post-exposure prophylaxis PEP after episodes of potential exposure. Disincentive to disclose HIV-related risk behaviours to healthcare professionals As discussed in the chapter: Proofdespite the ethical obligation of doctors and other healthcare professionals to maintain confidentiality, legal mechanisms such as search warrants and court orders can allow for confidentiality to be breached.

This may reduce the likelihood of honest and open discussions between people living with HIV and healthcare professionals regarding their sexual behaviour, reducing opportunities for sexual-health screening and support to reduce HIV-related risk taking. A 2009 essay examining the impact of prosecutions on people living with HIV in several Australian states reported that confidence in patient confidentiality had fallen due to fears that information could be obtained by the police and used to prosecute sexual risk-taking behaviour.

Canada — Doctor's testimony over 'safer sex' discussion used as evidence. In a 2008 trial for sexual assault and aggravated assault in Quebec, the case hinged on whether the female defendant had engaged in a single instance of unprotected sex without disclosing her HIV-positive status at the start of a five-year relationship.

There was no dispute over whether condoms were subsequently used.

  • Emerging HIV infectious diseases and the injection of illicit psychoactive drugs;
  • Breast-feeding, the cornerstone of child health and survival strategies, plays an important role in reducing infant mortality in many countries;
  • Global burden of tuberculosis;
  • This assumption is likely to underestimate the impact of the pandemic on production, because the replacement of skilled labour is a slow and expensive task, and labour cannot be shifted simply from one sector to another agriculture to health care, for example in response to shortages in skills;
  • International research is underway in this area, undertaken by a global partnership of local, national and international communities and organisations.

Her doctor's testimony included repeating a confidential discussion they had at the time about maintaining sexual practises. During that discussion the woman admitted to a single instance of unprotected intercourse, and this was admitted into evidence. In his ruling 27Judge Marc Bisson noted that the doctor's testimony was the only convincing piece of evidence supporting the prosecution's case.

Consequently, it is likely that the woman would not have been convicted had she not talked frankly about safer sex with her doctor. The woman was a given a one-year sentence to be served in the community due to her fragile health.

The negative impact on public health

Researchers in the United Kingdom have reported reluctance on the part of HIV-positive individuals to participate in studies where they disclose their sexual behaviour because of fears about the possibility that what they disclosed could be used against them in criminal prosecutions. Anecdotal evidence suggests that, in some cases, media reports have actually persuaded some people at high risk of being HIV-positive to test, particularly when they have had prior sexual contact with the accused.

There are, in fact, no data suggesting that people are inclined to delay or avoid testing specifically due to fear of criminal or other legal consequences. The findings in such modelling exercises are predicated on the access to comprehensive counselling and support by those people who are newly diagnosed. The impact on people at risk of acquiring HIV It has been asserted that using the criminal law to address potential or actual HIV exposure or transmission produces conflicting messages regarding who is responsible for HIV prevention.

If people at risk fail to recognise this, and think instead that HIV-positive sexual partners should and will always disclose their status, they may fail to take steps to reduce their risk of becoming infected.

SEXUAL TRANSMISSION

There appears to be only one published study examining the views of at-risk people in relation to the use of the criminal law, disclosure and misconceptions about responsiblities for HIV prevention. Drawing on data from more than 12,000 gay and bisexual men in the United Kingdom, Dodds and colleagues found that most men who were or believed themselves to be HIV-negative approved of criminal prosecutions in cases involving HIV-positive people who had failed to disclose their status before having sex.

Economic impact of HIV/AIDS

Despite the fact that accurate up-to-date information about HIV is widely available in the communities represented by the study population, most of the men who supported prosecutions considered HIV to be invariably fatal.

Having this erroneous belief, the researchers noted, may lead to assumptions that people who look well, and do not disclose that they are HIV-negative, are free from the virus. The same researchers found that as support for the use of the criminal law increased, so did expectations of disclosure. Harmmany people receive information about HIV through the popular media, primarily through news reports.

The same is likely to be true for the provenance of most people's information about HIV and the criminal law, including police, prosecutors, judges, potential complainants and defendants.

  • This study also showed that TB preventive therapy is cost-effective;
  • Unlike the industrialized countries, where HIV-infected mothers are counseled not to breast-feed and safe alternative breast-feeding practices are available, breast-feeding is prevalent in most developing countries.

All news media report stories in ways that are intended to reach their specific audiences, within the parameters of their format. However, some media outlets and the journalists who work within them are able to provide more detailed, factual HIV-related reporting because their format and audience allow that to happen.

The impact of HIV and AIDS on Africa's economic development

In other cases, the news media report stories about HIV in ways that work for their format and style — often grabbing their reader's or viewer's attention by focusing on stories that are "deviant, equivocal, and unpredictable" and covering them with a relatively small amount of text or factual explanation of the situation.

For example, when a Texas court sentenced a 42-year-homeless man with HIV to 35 years in prison after finding him guilty of using his saliva as a 'deadly weapon', only three of the 175 mainstream news reports actually mentioned that HIV cannot be transmitted via spitting.

  1. Consequently, it is likely that the woman would not have been convicted had she not talked frankly about safer sex with her doctor. AIDS also has costly consequences, especially for the poor.
  2. HIV prevention among injecting drug users. There was no dispute over whether condoms were subsequently used.
  3. Researchers in the United Kingdom have reported reluctance on the part of HIV-positive individuals to participate in studies where they disclose their sexual behaviour because of fears about the possibility that what they disclosed could be used against them in criminal prosecutions. Risk factors for transmission through breast milk include high maternal virus load and mastitis 8 , 16 , 77.

International resources providing links to further information about HIV and the criminal law and accurate information on HIV-related harm, risk and responsibility can be found in the chapter: Accurate, factual and impartial sources of information about HIV and the criminal law, 4950 and about HIV-related harm, risk and responsibility, are available.

Those people who know they are living with HIV and who are in contact with HIV service providers, or members of high HIV-prevalence communities — such as gay men 51 or women in southern Africa 52 — may take advantage of these resources. See, for example, New Zealand: Summary of main issues and conclusions. Geneva, 2008 Burris S et al. The criminalization of HIV: HIV prevention programs depend on it.

You are here

Do criminal laws influence HIV risk behaviour? Arizona State Law Journal 39: Reproductive Health Matters 17 34: Sex Transm Inf 80: Online resource last updated 8 March 2010, available at: Social Science and Medicine, 65 4: Louis University Public Law Review 7: Geneva, 2009 Pinkerton SD et al.

  • In developing countries, transmission through the blood supply has yet to be eliminated, especially where HIV prevalence rates among blood donors are high and where screening of blood for HIV has not become routine 9 , 38 , 64 , 88 , 107;
  • The increase has coincided with new patterns of drug use, particularly the shift from smoking opiates to injecting drugs influenced by the increased availability and affordability of injectable heroin , and increased migration and population mixing 74 , 75 , 81;
  • This assumption is likely to underestimate the impact of the pandemic on production, because the replacement of skilled labour is a slow and expensive task, and labour cannot be shifted simply from one sector to another agriculture to health care, for example in response to shortages in skills.

J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 47: J Contemp Health Law Policy 9: Hart Publishing, 2008 Burris S Law and the social risk of health care: American Journal of Criminal Justice 25 1: